Price for Progress: The Ultimate JTBD Framework for Willingness-to-Pay

How to leverage JTBD to move beyond superficial pricing tactics and uncover what your customers truly value—and are therefore genuinely willing to pay for

Table of Contents

• The Price is Right... Or Is It?

• Why Traditional WTP Methods Fall Short

  • The Pitfalls of Asking Directly

  • Limitations of Competitor-Based Pricing

  • Cost-Plus Myopia

• The JTBD Lens: Connecting Value to Price

  • Core Concept

  • Identifying the Real Job (B2C vs. B2B nuances)

  • Uncovering Desired Outcomes (Needs)

  • Quantifying Value

• Novel Strategies for Determining WTP using JTBD

  • Strategy 1: Outcome-Driven WTP Assessment (Deep Dive)

  • Strategy 2: Contextual Inquiry & Value Observation

  • Strategy 3: Pricing by "Job Segment"

• Elevating the Level of Abstraction: The Future of Value and WTP

  • Today's Complexities

  • Novel Concept - The "Single Solution" for a Higher-Context Job

  • Impact on WTP

  • Different Job Performers

• Implementing JTBD-Based WTP in Your Business (Actionable Steps)

  • Step 1: Define Your Customer's Core Job(s).

  • Step 2: Uncover All Associated Desired Outcomes (Needs).

  • Step 3: Identify Which Outcomes are Underserved and Important.

  • Step 4: Analyze How Your Solution (and competitors') Addresses These Outcomes.

  • Step 5: Test WTP through value-based conversations and concept testing.

• Price for Progress, Not Just Product

The Price is Right... Or Is It?

Setting the right price for your product or service is one of the most critical decisions any business makes. Yet, it's an area fraught with uncertainty and often, flawed approaches. Many businesses default to cost-plus calculations, nervously glance at competitor price lists, or conduct willingness-to-pay (WTP) surveys that, frankly, don't always hit the mark.

The core problem? These traditional methods frequently fail to connect price to the genuine value a customer derives from your offering. They don't truly answer: "How much progress does this help my customer make, and what is that progress worth to them?"

This is where the Jobs-to-be-Done (JTBD) framework offers a more robust, insightful path. It posits that Willingness-to-Pay isn't arbitrary; it's a direct function of how well your solution helps a customer successfully complete a specific "job."

In this post, you'll learn how to leverage JTBD to move beyond superficial pricing tactics and uncover what your customers truly value—and are therefore genuinely willing to pay for. We'll explore practical strategies for both B2C and B2B contexts, helping you price with more confidence and precision.

Why Traditional WTP Methods Fall Short

Before diving into the JTBD approach, let's briefly touch upon why common pricing strategies often lead businesses astray.

The Pitfalls of Asking Directly

It seems logical: want to know what people will pay? Just ask them! However, direct WTP surveys have significant limitations:

• Hypothetical Bias: There's a well-documented gap between what people say they'll pay in a survey and what they'll actually pay when it's their own money on the line.

• Lack of Context: Surveys often present pricing questions in a vacuum, detached from the real-world buying situation and the full value proposition.

• Anchoring and Framing Effects: How you ask the question, and the price points you suggest, can heavily influence the answers, leading to skewed data.

Limitations of Competitor-Based Pricing

Looking at what your competitors charge can provide a benchmark, but it's a dangerous strategy to rely on exclusively:

• Race to the Bottom: If everyone prices relative to each other without a clear understanding of their unique value, it can lead to price wars that erode profitability for all.

• Ignores Your Unique Value Proposition: Your solution might solve the customer's job better, faster, or more completely than a competitor's. Pricing solely based on competitors means you might be undervaluing your unique advantages.

• Assumes Competitors Have It Right: What if your competitors are also guessing or using flawed pricing models?

Cost-Plus Myopia

Calculating your costs and adding a standard markup is simple, but it's an internally focused approach:

• Not Customer-Value Focused: This method completely ignores the perceived value to the customer. A low-cost product that solves a critical job extremely well might command a much higher price than simple cost-plus would suggest.

• Leaves Money on the Table: If the value you deliver is substantially higher than your costs plus a modest markup, you're missing out on significant revenue and profit opportunities.

The JTBD Lens: Connecting Value to Price

Jobs-to-be-Done theory offers a paradigm shift: instead of focusing on your product or your costs, you focus on the customer's "job."

Core Concept

The fundamental idea is that customers "hire" products or services to make progress in a specific situations – to get a "job" done. They are willing to pay for solutions that help them achieve their desired outcomes related to that job more effectively, reliably, or conveniently than alternatives.

Identifying the Real Job (B2C vs. B2B nuances)

Understanding the actual job is crucial, and it often requires digging deeper than the surface-level task. The context also matters – B2C and B2B jobs, while following the same principles, often have different primary drivers.

• B2C Example: A person doesn't just "buy a coffee machine." The underlying job might be to "get a reliably great cup of coffee quickly and easily at home to start my day feeling energized and prepared." Different solutions (drip machine, espresso maker, pod system) might be hired for this job, and WTP will depend on how well each fulfills the key desired outcomes (taste, speed, ease, consistency).

• B2B Example: A company doesn't just "buy CRM software." A core job might be to "improve sales team efficiency and effectiveness to increase revenue and market share." The CRM is a tool hired to achieve outcomes like "minimize time spent on data entry," "maximize lead conversion rates," or "improve sales forecasting accuracy."

Uncovering Desired Outcomes (Needs)

For every Job-to-be-Done, there's a set of desired outcomes (often called customer needs, or success metrics). These are the metrics customers use, consciously or unconsciously, to evaluate how well a solution helps them get the job done. These outcomes are stable over time, even as solutions evolve.

When defining these outcomes, it's powerful to use clear, actionable language. Think in terms of what the customer wants to achieve, avoid, minimize, or maximize (referencing approaches like those in "Verbs for Job Statements"). For instance:

• Minimize the time it takes to...

• Increase the likelihood of...

• Reduce the errors that occur when...

That’s right, there is more than one direction and/or verb!

Quantifying Value

The more unmet and important desired outcomes your solution addresses significantly better than any alternative, the higher the perceived value you offer. This increased value is the foundation upon which a stronger willingness-to-pay is built. It’s not about adding more features; it’s about delivering better on the outcomes that matter most to the customer for their job.

Novel Strategies for Determining WTP using JTBD

Armed with a JTBD perspective, you can employ more insightful strategies to gauge willingness-to-pay.

Strategy 1: Outcome-Driven WTP Assessment (Deep Dive)

This is about systematically identifying your customers' desired outcomes for a specific job and then determining which of those are both important and currently underserved by existing solutions (yours and competitors').

• How it works: Through qualitative research (like customer interviews/AI-modeling focused on the job) and potentially quantitative surveys (rating importance and satisfaction/effort of outcomes), you can pinpoint these "opportunity areas."

• WTP Indication: A high degree of importance combined with low current satisfaction (or high effort) for an outcome signals a significant pain point or unmet need. Customers are generally willing to pay more for solutions that effectively address these specific, high-value outcomes.

• Example: If B2B customers consistently state that "minimizing the risk of data breaches during cloud migration" is extremely important, but current solutions leave them feeling vulnerable (low satisfaction), a new service that demonstrably and significantly reduces this risk can command a premium price. You're not just selling a feature; you're selling "peace of mind" and "risk reduction" for a critical job.

Strategy 2: Contextual Inquiry & Value Observation

This strategy emphasizes understanding WTP not by asking directly, but by observing customers as they attempt to get their job done in their natural environment.

• How it works: Go where the job happens. Observe users interacting with current solutions (or their workarounds if no good solution exists). Pay close attention to points of friction, frustration, inefficiencies, and where they invest significant time or resources to compensate for shortcomings in current products/services. (This aligns with understanding the "Consumption Chain" – all the steps a customer goes through from purchase to disposal – as outlined in strong research frameworks.)

• WTP Indication: The efforts customers expend on workarounds, the time they lose due to inefficiencies, or the costs they incur from problems with existing solutions all represent latent willingness-to-pay for something better. If a customer is duct-taping three tools together and spending 5 hours a week on manual data reconciliation, that's a clear signal they'd value (and pay for) an integrated solution that automates it.

• Working today (but few do it rigorously): While many companies do user research, truly deep ethnographic studies focused on the entire job context (not just product usability) are less common but incredibly powerful for uncovering these WTP insights.

Strategy 3: Pricing by "Job Segment"

Instead of relying solely on demographic or firmographic segments, consider segmenting your market based on how different groups of customers prioritize desired outcomes for the same core job.

• How it works: Even for one broadly defined job (e.g., "manage personal finances"), different customer groups will have different clusters of highly important, underserved outcomes. One segment might prioritize "maximize investment returns with minimal effort," while another prioritizes "ensure I never miss a bill payment and avoid late fees."

• WTP Indication: These "job segments" will have different WTP for features or service levels that cater specifically to their top-priority outcomes. You can then tailor different versions of your offering (or different service tiers) with price points that reflect the distinct value delivered to each segment.

• Example: For the job of "plan a family vacation," one segment might highly value "minimizing the stress of planning" and be willing to pay for a full-service travel agent or a highly curated planning tool. Another segment might prioritize "maximizing the adventure on a limited budget" and be more willing to pay for access to unique, off-the-beaten-path deals, even if it requires more planning effort on their part.

Elevating the Level of Abstraction: The Future of Value and WTP

The JTBD framework not only helps in understanding current WTP but also in envisioning future opportunities, especially when we consider "elevating the level of abstraction" in how jobs get done.

Today's Complexities

Many jobs customers are trying to accomplish today are inherently complex. They often require juggling multiple tools, integrating different services, and possessing a significant amount of domain expertise or learned skill.

• Example (B2C): Effectively managing personal health and fitness might involve a diet tracking app, a workout app, a wearable sensor, regular consultations with a nutritionist, and a gym membership. The WTP is fragmented across these components.

• Example (B2B): Launching and managing a successful digital marketing campaign might require separate tools and expertise for SEO, content creation, social media management, paid advertising (PPC), email marketing, and analytics.

Novel Concept - The "Single Solution" for a Higher-Context Job

Imagine a future where a novel solution emerges that doesn't just improve one piece of the current fragmented process but instead gets the entire, higher-context job done in a fundamentally different, radically simpler, and more effective way.

• Key Characteristic: These solutions often appear to have fewer visible features or require less direct user manipulation because the underlying complexity is intelligently managed and abstracted away from the user. The focus shifts from manipulating tools to achieving the overarching goal.

• Example: Instead of a business owner needing to learn and operate five distinct marketing tools, a future AI-driven platform might take a high-level goal like "acquire 100 new qualified leads this month within X budget" and autonomously execute and optimize the necessary activities, presenting only key results and strategic choices to the user.

I just heard about a product called headai.io. It essentially eliminates your entire marketing stack … including all the people. It claims to do everything marketing organization or agency can do. Everything! This is what the next level of abstraction looks like.

Impact on WTP

This "elevation of abstraction" can have profound impacts on willingness-to-pay:

• Premium for Complete Solution: Customers may be willing to pay a significant premium for a single, elegant solution that perfectly and effortlessly gets their entire higher-level job done, thereby eliminating the cost, time, and cognitive load of managing multiple partial solutions. The value is in the completeness and the drastically improved experience.

• Disruption through Lower Total Cost: Conversely, such a novel solution might also be disruptive by offering a lower total cost of ownership. Even if the price of the single solution is higher than any one individual component it replaces, it could be less than the sum of all previous components, plus the implicit costs of user effort and expertise.

• Value in Simplicity: The reduction in complexity itself is a powerful value driver. Customers will often pay to avoid hassle, reduce learning curves, and achieve their desired outcomes with less mental effort.

Different Job Performers

A fascinating consequence of these highly abstracted, powerful solutions is that they can change who performs the job.

• Tasks that once required highly skilled (and expensive) specialists might become accessible to generalists or even automated.

• Example: Complex data analysis that once required a statistician might be performed by a business manager using an intuitive AI analytics tool. This democratizes capability and can reshape the WTP landscape, as the "buyer" or "user" profile changes.

Implementing JTBD-Based WTP in Your Business (Actionable Steps)

Translating JTBD theory into practical WTP strategies involves a systematic approach:

Step 1: Define Your Customer's Core Job(s).

Start by clearly articulating the fundamental job(s) your target customers are trying to get done, for which your product/service could be hired. Be specific. Instead of "communication," think "collaborate effectively with remote team members on time-sensitive projects."

Step 2: Uncover All Associated Desired Outcomes (Needs).

Through qualitative customer research (interviews, observations), map out all the desired outcomes (or needs) customers have related to getting that job done. Use the customer's language. Aim for a comprehensive list. (Leverage techniques from robust research frameworks, such as mapping out the entire customer journey or consumption chain and identifying success metrics for each step).

Step 3: Identify Which Outcomes are Underserved and Important.

Quantify (e.g., via surveys) the importance of each outcome to your customers and how satisfied they are with current solutions in achieving that outcome. The sweet spot for value creation lies in addressing outcomes that are highly important but poorly satisfied.

Step 4: Analyze How Your Solution (and competitors') Addresses These Outcomes.

Objectively assess how well your offering delivers on the most important and underserved outcomes compared to alternatives. This highlights your true differentiation and areas where you can justifiably support a price aligned with the superior value delivered.

Step 5: Test WTP through value-based conversations and concept testing.

Instead of bluntly asking "How much would you pay for this?", frame pricing discussions around the value of solving specific, critical pain points or achieving key desired outcomes.

• Use concept tests for new offerings, describing how they address underserved outcomes, and then explore perceived value (e.g., "If a solution could consistently help you achieve X outcome, saving you Y hours per week, what would that be worth to your business?").

• For existing products, value-based conversations can reveal if current pricing aligns with the perceived value of the outcomes being delivered.

Price for Progress, Not Just Product

The Jobs-to-be-Done framework offers a powerful lens to fundamentally rethink your approach to pricing and willingness-to-pay. By shifting your focus from your product's features or your internal costs to the customer's job and their desired outcomes, you unlock a much deeper understanding of what they truly value.

This understanding is the bedrock of an effective, value-based pricing strategy. It allows you to price with greater confidence, capture more of the value you create, and build offerings that resonate more deeply with your customers' needs. Stop pricing features; start pricing the progress you enable.

---

What's the biggest challenge you face in determining willingness-to-pay in your business? Or have you used a JTBD-like approach to pricing with success? Share your experiences and questions in the comments below!

BONUS: Check out this cheat sheet! https://www.pjtbd.com/price-for-progress

Follow me on 𝕏: https://x.com/mikeboysen

If you’d like to take action, I would love to help. Here’s are some steps you can take to make that a reality for us:

1. Join my community and get access to more content and tools

2. Apply for coaching so we can do projects together and build a new business-as-usual with someone who will share the knowledge, and hold you accountable. (I have limited seats so hurry!)

3. I do project work as well. Use the coaching link and we can discuss.

Why Me?

My schedule is often booked months in advance.

I’ve been trained by the best in Outcome-Driven Innovation. Part of that training involved how to understand what the future should look like. As a result, I’ve taken what I’ve learned and begun innovating so I can get you to the outcomes you’re seeking faster, better, and even more predictably. Anyone preaching innovation should be doing the same; regardless of how disruptive it’ll be.

How am I doing this?

• I’ve developed a complete toolset that accelerates qualitative research to mere hours instead of the weeks or months it used to take. It’s been fine-tuned over the past 2+ years and it’s second-to-none (including to humans). That means we can have far more certainty that we’ve properly framed your research before you invest in a basket of road apples. They don’t taste good, even with whipped cream on top.

• I’m also working on a completely new concept for prioritizing market dynamics that predict customer needs (and success) without requiring time-consuming and costly surveys with low quality participants. This is far more powerful and cost effective than the point-in-time surveys that I know you don’t want to do!

I believe that an innovation consultant should eat their own dog food. Therefore, we must always strive to:

• Get more of the job done for our clients

• Get the job done better for our clients

• Get the job done faster for our clients

• Get the job done with with fewer features for our clients

• Get the job done in a completely different and novel way for our clients

• Get the job done in a less costly manner for our clients

But more importantly, I strive to deliver high quality and high availability. That's why I also have to be choosy.

All the links you need are a few paragraphs up. Or set up some time to talk … that link is down below. 👇🏻

Mike Boysen - www.pjtbd.com
Why fail fast when you can succeed the first time?

📆 Book an appointment: https://pjtbd.com/book-mike

Update your small business tech stack: https://pjtbd.com/tech-stack